Picky Eaters Can Die (Ex: Me)

One of my favorite past times is eating out. I love going to a restaurant, being seated, having a waiter bring me a drink, and relaxing with friends as we chat and look over our menus. And that’s where the problem begins for me. Because, usually, I take a really long time deciding what to eat. I’m such a picky eater it’s almost pathetic. Even if I’ve eaten at the restaurant about 84 times in the past, I always look through the menu front to back at least once. And then I’ll finally decide on two meals, and take some more time deciding which would be better. It’s really cute, actually (no, not really).

Today I spent over ten minutes looking over the menu at this restaurant I love to eat at, Applebee’s, and it was ten minutes too many. My family would look over at me with their hungry eyes and quietly urge me to cut the shit, and I don’t blame them. After questioning my meal choice to see if it was what I really wanted, pondering the possible calories in the meal, and making a pros-and-cons list (mentally, of course), I decided on grilled cheese. Grilled cheese. I’m sorry, what?

Next time, I’ll look at the restaurant’s menu online to preserve my sanity, and that of the people I dine with. It’s only fair.


I’m not very picky. I like all sorts of food, and I am willing to try new things. But I am certainly indecisive. It’s to the point where I’m not even allowed to make a decision at some restaurants, I just have one meal at each place that I get. At White Spot, I always have a Bacon Cheddar Burger, at the Green Olive I always have Mare E Monte pasta, etc etc. It’s a sad, but necessary measure, to ensure my dining companions do not murder me. :)

Posted by Aisling on April 26, 2008

I’m a picky eater too - so much so that there are usually only a few items on restaurant menus that I’m willing to eat. When I arrive at a restaurant, I glance over the menu quickly eliminating the 80-90% of it that I “can’t” eat due to my pickiness. Then, I squander five more minutes on deciding between the 2-5 items I’ve deemed acceptable.

Posted by Chantelle on April 26, 2008

I am not a picky eater AT ALL...I almost always like the sound of everything on the menu, so mine is more a problem of too much choice, rather than not enough choice.

What I’ve found works well for me, is to simply check out what other people are eating (e.g. the diners at other tables close to me), and just say “I’ll have what they’re having” if it looks good…

Posted by Amanda on April 27, 2008

I agree with Amanda’s comment- I’m no picky eater, I just can’t decide on what to order! lol

I did that last night. I kinda sat there at the table and said to myself, “These all look good, I want it all!” haha

Posted by Elle on April 27, 2008

Haha.  If I go to a restaurant I’ve been to before, I know what I’m going to order before I even get there, but I still spend 439587 minutes looking at the menu just to pretend I might get something different.  But it never happens. :P

Posted by Maren on April 27, 2008

I’m a really picky eater, too!  When I go to a restaurant I always know in advance that I am going to order one of a few things: breakfast, something chicken based, or a fish meal.  That’s it.  Every single time.  :)

Posted by Erica on April 27, 2008

I’m a really picky eater too, although I don’t take long in deciding what I want to eat. I just don’t like my food to be too ‘fancy’. Plain and normal is fine for me.

Posted by Chans on April 27, 2008

lol, I’m picky too. But, I know what I like. So it’s easy for my to go through menus quickly.

Posted by (Olivia) on April 27, 2008

I’m a very picky eater as well, but I know exactly what I want, so it saves time.  The only thing is that I’m scared to try new stuff.

Posted by Regina on April 27, 2008

I’m a very picky/fussy eater. You can imagine how it’ll be on a dinner date? Totally unromantic, that’s what. ;_; I usually make my friends order for me, or choose something well in the “safe” boundary if I don’t trust them. :3

Posted by Jenny on April 27, 2008

I am picky eater, plus I can’t decide what I want to eat even if I’m given only options of things I like. That rarely happens though… I usually don’t like absolutely anything that’s on the menu.
I always get all excited when I’m going to eat out, only to remember once I’m there with the menu on my hands that I rarely find anything I like to order. The last time I went to a fancy restaurant with my dad and his fiancĂ© I was all happy until I got there. I left really angry because everything they served was specially disgusting. And it was all made of meat (I don’t eat meat :P)… they had things like “meat stuff with fish”, “fish stuffed with meat”, “fish stuffed with potatoes” “potatoes stuffed with meat”. I wanted to puke. Plus they had a huge, disgusting, stinky dead lobster in a fish tank next to our table.

*sobs*

Posted by Lene on April 27, 2008

It always takes me a long time to choose what I want to eat for dinner as well. I wouldn’t say that I’m a picky eater per se, but I’m just way too indecisive. I’m always afraid that I’m going to spend my money on something that is nasty :P.

Posted by Yara on April 27, 2008

When I eat out, it can only be in an Italian restaurant. I shall have garlic bread for a start if applicable, and a plain margherita pizza for the main meal.

I can’t eat anywhere else due to my food issues. :(

Posted by Rachael on April 27, 2008

You went to Applebee’s and got a GRILLED CHEESE??? As “Rick James” would say—“SLAP!!”

I am NOT a picky eater… at all. I mean, there *are* some things that I just cannot bring myself to eat, like octopus or calamari (or most seafood, really), but I love trying new things! The problem usually lies on how much it costs. Whenever I go out to a restaurant it’s usually because I got invited so I don’t want to order something *too* costly and feel bad afterwards.

Posted by Robmarie on April 27, 2008

I’m pretty picky myself. Actually, it probably has more to do with my indecisiveness. Sometimes it takes more than 10 minutes that figure out what I want. I even make a fuss over what I’m going to have to drink.

Posted by Kiera on April 28, 2008

I’m a picky eater too, but when it comes to restaurants, I always get a cheeseburger and fries :3

Posted by Hannah on April 28, 2008

While I’m not a picky eater at all, I do have the same issue as far as taking forever to order.  I’d probably eat just about anything on any menu handed to me, but I’m picky when it comes to what I really want at the moment.  I weigh my options, leaving out the calories and carbs, and usually get it pinned down to two or three things.  Then I’m stuck playing “eenie, meenie, miney, moe”, in which case I’m not always sure of the selection.  It takes me forever but everyone I ever eat with knows this and they are stuck dealing with it.  I think the waitress coming back every 3 seconds to ask if I’ve decided yet pressures me more then the people I’m dining with.

Posted by on April 28, 2008
Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.